State-Building In Religious Society: A Comparative Study Of Religious Control In Belt And Road Countries

Post Author(s)

This research aims to study state policies of the religious control in Belt and Road countries in Central Asia, including China (Xinjiang province), Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, and Tajikistan. Through a comparative study of the religious policies in these countries, this study seeks to reveal how the socialist or post-socialist authorities govern and control religious people. To wit, this refers to how to transform people’s infrastructure of faith from the faith in gods to the faith in the states.

China is the initiator of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), attempting to strengthen the infrastructure and ties between China and other countries of Asia. Nonetheless, an unintended effect of the BRI is that the increased communication and association between Belt and Road countries facilitate and intensify religious circulations in these societies. Religious groups sharing the same infrastructure of faith connect each other, establish transnational networks, and organize interstate activities. The circulation and penetration of religious networks make state leaders feel threatened. So, they have made a set of policies to strengthen religious control over people. How to change people’s infrastructure of faith from the faith in gods to the faith in states is the kernel of the policies.

China’s religious policies directed at the religious ethnic minorities of Xinjiang beget severe criticism from the international community; however, the post-socialist republics of central Asia carry out comparable policies of religious control, albeit less radical or extreme. We can see the structural similarity of these policies and measures: building infrastructures of religious control and repression. This research will compare the policies and infrastructures built by China and central Asian republics on the Belt and Road to control and manage their Muslim populations, and will examine to what extent the BRI leads to stronger or weaker religious repression.

This research enriches our understanding of state-building in the Central Asia countries, an underdeveloped area for a long time. Moreover, through the comparative analysis, we can see China’s impacts on its adjacent countries. These impacts are not only economic and political but also cultural and religious. Finally, by comparing the religious efforts of the five states, I will develop a general explanation of the dilemma state leaders have encountered when building a strong state in a strongly religious society. The challenges from religion to modern states are ubiquitous in most countries in the world. So, the theory developed from this research can be widely applied to other countries. 

Religious Circulation, Transportation Routes, And Urban Space: Christianity In Late Imperial And Modern China

This project studies the intricate and largely overlooked relationship between religious circulation, transportation routes and urban space in the historical context of state building and global connection in mid-eighteenth to mid-twentieth-century China. Focusing on the case of Christianity, it examines three cities and regions that have played...

Mapping Routes, Exchange, And Transformation Along The Borderlands Of Laos, China, And Vietnam: The Lanten Case

Political and, often, scholarly, boundaries divide Asia artificially into units, such as Southeast Asia and China. This modern division often contributes to masking ongoing processes of exchange and flow of persons, goods and ideas, and societies inhabiting the borderlands. Such is the case of the Lanten communities (Landian Yao or Yao Mun) who...

Between A Rock And A Hard Place: Sinophobia And Religious Nationalist Sentiments In Vietnam

President Xi Jinping’s launch of the One Bell One Road Initiative (OBOR or BRI) was met with a negative reaction in the Vietnamese public sphere, although the speedy development of infrastructure connecting Vietnam and China would stimulate a number of trade sectors. The discussion focused on whether part of Vietnamese sovereignty should be given...

Building Inter-Asia New Age Networks: Balancing Heterodoxy And Patriotism In Chinese Spiritual Tourism To India

The recent military clashes between India and China in the Galwan Valley resulted in the Sino-Indian border heating up to levels unseen in recent years. Meanwhile, India continues to downplay China’s Belt and Road Initiative and refuses to sign a BRI Memorandum of Understanding. In June 2020, parallel to the reports on these tensions, Chinese...

Mapping the online discourse on the BRI in social media: general context and religious factors

This data mining project investigates the changing and contested narratives of the BRI in social media, focusing on sentimental and networking characteristics in online communication platforms. In an interim outcome, this work has firstly framed a systematic approach to analyse the discourse on the BRI in social networking platforms; with further...

Inter-Asian Learning And Teaching Across The Belt And Road: In-Between Pakistani Madrasah And Chinese School

Driven by the steady increase of the Muslim population, ethnic Muslims in Hong Kong have been desperately seeking physical space for daily prayer and reciting Qur’an. Out of the strong religious aspiration, many small-scale madrasah (‘housques’) have been flourishing in many parts of Hong Kong in recent years. Based on my ongoing ethnographic...

BRI Mapbox: An Online Map Generating Database

The BRI Mapbox illustrates the spatial configuration between infrastructures and religious factors in the BRI region. This work maps out and correlates routes, borders, railroads, pipelines, ports and free trade zones with demographic, economic and geo-political data in both contemporary and retrospective timeframes. These spatial features form a...

Parallels And Paradoxes: New Religious Formations In Response To The BRI In Sri Lanka

Since the end of the civil war in 2009, Sri Lanka has attracted significant volumes of foreign investment. The vast majority of this investment has come from Chinese companies, which have committed loans amounting to over US$ 7 billion so far. Much of this investment has been used to finance large-scale infrastructure projects, including the...

Sacralizing The Works, Engaging Inter-Cultural Relations: Stories Of Indonesian Female Muslim Workers In Hong Kong

Alhamdulillah (thanks to God), I made my hijrah (literally migration, from sinful to righteously pious -better- Muslim). I had intended to do so for years, but finally made it since last year. It's been a year now," said a niqab-ed Indonesian female Muslim worker in her monthly religious gathering at victoria Park of Hong Kong, in October 28th,...

Spacializing the BRI in the History of Asian Imperial Imaginations

This subproject situates the contemporary mapping of the BRI within the history of the spacial imagination of Asia, using the notion of “empire” as a conceptual tool to interrogate how the connecting and separation of places through networks and infrastructures of trade and religion have been associated with different imaginations, juxtapositions...